Australian Natural Resources Atlas

Natural Resource Topics

Australian Catchment, River and Estuary Assessment 2002

National Land and Water Resources Audit, 2002
ISBN 0 642 37125 3

Findings

The loss of riparian vegetation results in bank erosion and increased nutrient and sediment loads to the river.

The loss of riparian vegetation results in bank erosion and increased nutrient and sediment loads to the river.

Photo: Jim Tait

The results of the river assessment show the extent of change in Australia's river basins. Change in condition is most strongly linked to:

Hydrological change related to impoundments and water extraction is a significant driver of river condition. A hydrological baseline was, however, available for only 25% of the number of river reaches in the assessment (or 30% of the total river length) making it difficult to measure the extent to which flow regulation and abstraction have affected rivers. It was found that the two most affected aspects of hydrology are the flow duration (40% of assessed river length is modified) and the seasonal amplitude (30% of assessed river length is modified). This means that flows are usually for longer periods than pre-European settlement flows, and the seasonal peaks and lows of intermittent systems are evened out to resemble perennial systems (see box p. 59).

Aquatic biota index (macro-invertebrates)

One-third (21 909 km) of the river length assessed is to some degree impaired (has lost between 20% and 100% of the various kinds of aquatic invertebrates that should live there) (Figure 37, Table 11).

Assessment results are underestimates of change in some parts of the country, including the lowland rivers of the Murray-Darling Basin and Western Australia. In these areas the reference sites used as benchmarks have already been modified to some extent since European settlement.

These findings on the biotic condition of Australia's rivers need to be considered in the context of the commitment to ecologically sustainable development. Extensive change to riverine ecosystems has already occurred, and with the assessment of river condition providing only a measure of condition, not trend, it may be that this change is continuing. It was beyond the scope of this assessment to ascertain whether the extent of change detected was ecologically sustainable. Ecosystems have a natural resilience to disturbance. Beyond a certain level of disturbance, ecosystem structures and processes fail. Less desirable ecosystems (e.g. lowland river ecosystems may change from macrophyte-dominated systems to systems dominated by cyanobacterial blooms) may result.

Figure 37: Condition of river reaches based on the aquatic biota (macro-invertebrates) index.
Table 11: Aquatic biota index (macro-invertebrates) results for each State and Territory.
  Total length of reach (km) in each category and percentage of total in parentheses Percentage of total length with data
Reference Significantly impaired Severely impaired Extremely impaired
Queensland 9 334 (80) 1 997 (17) 250 (2) 16 (1) 16
New South Wales 11 366 (50) 7 551 (34) 2 801 (13) 690 (3) 38
Australian Capital Territory 169 (64) 76 (29) 17 (7) 0 (0) 97
Victoria 9 347 (76) 2 447 (20) 344 (3) 49 (1) 77
Tasmania 4 248 (75) 1 097 (20) 142 (3) 100 (2) 100
South Australia 7 866 (83) 1 098 (12) 124 (1) 389 (4) 98
Western Australia 4 401 (64) 1 977 (29) 419 (6) 31 (1) 27
Northern Territory 2 063 (88) 247 (10) 47 (2) 0 (0) 11
Total 48 793 (69) 16 490 (23) 4 144 (6) 1 275 (2) 34

Environment index

 The Condamine River between Dalby and Cecil Plains (Queensland) showing poor catchment condition.

The Condamine River between Dalby and Cecil Plains (Queensland) showing poor catchment condition.

Photo: Natural Resouces and Mines, Queensland

The environment index combines the subindices of catchment disturbance, habitat, hydrological disturbance, and nutrient and suspended sediment load. Some components were not sufficiently comprehensive to fully characterise the driver of river condition (e.g. a water quality index would ideally consider important drivers of water quality, such as nutrients, suspended sediments, salt, turbidity, temperature, dissolved oxygen concentrations and toxicants). Comprehensive data was available for nutrient and suspended sediment loads only.

Increases in nutrients and suspended sediment loads, and decreases in the extent of riparian vegetation have resulted in 85% of the river length being assessed as substantially or moderately modified from natural condition (Table 12, Figure 38). In the Northern Territory, two-thirds of the river length assessed is in largely unmodified condition. In all other States and Territories except Tasmania, more than 80% of the river length assessed is substantially or moderately modified. One of the objectives of the assessment of river condition is to provide information on possible causes of degradation and inform management decisions on appropriate courses of action. Examination of the subindex results that make up the overall environment index is useful and can assist management as detailed in following sections.

Table 12: River environment index results for each State and Territory.
  Total length of reach (km) in each category and percentage of total in parentheses Percentage of total length with data
Largely unmodified Moderately modified Substantially modified Extensively modified
Queensland 8 743 (13) 48 214 (71) 10 599 (16) 0 (0) 93
New South Wales 1 619 (3) 39 232 (68) 17 089 (29) 18 (0) 97
Australian Capital Territory 43 (16) 191 (71) 36 (13) 0 (0) 100
Victoria 3 085 (20) 9 042 (60) 3 099 (20) 0 (0) 97
Tasmania 2 028 (37) 3 250 (59) 194 (4) 0 (0) 98
South Australia 299 (4) 4 666 (61) 2 635 (35) 0 (0) 79
Western Australia 1 487 (7) 15 927 (78) 2 929 (14) 12 (1) 80
Northern Territory 9 165 (66) 4 630 (34) 0 (0) 0 (0) 67
Total 26 468 (14) 125 152 (66) 36 581 (19) 31 (1) 90
Figure 38: Condition of river reaches based on the environment index.

Catchment disturbance

Approximately 85% of river length assessed has catchments that have been changed from a natural condition (Table 13). Changes to land use are considered to have the most potential to affect rivers.

Both extent of recent land clearing and land use change are considered by this subindex. Changes tend to be widespread and relatively uniform, reflecting the predominance of broad-acre agriculture. Urban development, and more intensive agriculture have impact on rivers in some localised areas, particularly along the east and south-east coasts. Included in the measure of catchment disturbance is the influence of infrastructure (roads, power lines, railways) on rivers. Infrastructure had a less significant effect on river condition than land use, but was very important in densely populated areas.

Table 13: River catchment disturbance subindex for each State and Territory.
  Total length of reach (km) in each category and percentage of total in parentheses Percentage of total length with data
Largely unmodified Moderately modified Substantially modified Extensively modified
Queensland 5 119 (7) 66 623 (93) 300 (0) 0 (0) 98
New South Wales 5 773 (10) 52 343 (90) 216 (0) 32 (0) 95
Australian Capital Territory 158 (59) 105 (39) 7 (2) 0 (0) 95
Victoria 1 716 (11) 11 479 (74) 2 208 (14) 87 (1) 95
Tasmania 2 455 (44) 2 918 (52) 213 (4) 0 (0) 96
South Australia 463 (5) 8 422 (90) 519 (5) 70 (0) 94
Western Australia 6 038 (24) 19 149 (76) 8 (0) 12 (0) 94
Northern Territory 8 752 (43) 11 739 (57) 0 (0) 0 (0) 97
Total 30 474 (15) 172 778 (83) 3 470 (2) 202 (0) 99

Habitat change

Murrumbidgee River (New South Wales) with instream habitat impacted by increased bedload.

Murrumbidgee River (New South Wales) with instream habitat impacted by increased bedload.

Photo: Cooperative Research Centre for Freshwater Ecology.

Over half of the rivers in the assessed area are affected by changes to riverine habitat, with the most modified areas occurring in the Murray-Darling Basin, South Australia and parts of the Western Australian wheatbelt (Table 14, Figure 39). The main indicators linked to this degradation are loss of riparian vegetation and increased sediment loads in rivers; a third habitat measure used was change to upstream-downstream and overbank connectivity.

Riparian vegetation plays a number of key roles in river ecosystem processes, particularly in those rivers with extensive floodplains (e.g. the lowland sections of the rivers flowing west from the Great Dividing Range). In these extensive floodplain areas, the loss of riparian vegetation is high.

Increased sediment loads in streams have led to:

The bedload condition in about 66% of the rivers in the assessed area is either only slightly modified or unchanged. These reaches are not considered susceptible to accelerated deposition of sand and gravel because they are in areas of low catchment disturbance, have high sediment transport capacity or are far away from the source of bed material.

Change to upstream-downstream and overbank connectivity is most affected where reservoirs have been built - in the mid-slopes region along the Great Australian Divide and in Tasmania.

Table 14: River habitat subindex for each State and Territory.
  Total length of reach (km) in each category and percentage of total in parentheses Percentage of total length with data
Largely unmodified Moderately modified Substantially modified Extensively modified
Queensland 45 389 (66) 18 184 (27) 4 263 (6) 130 (1) 94
New South Wales 15 724 (27) 19 695 (33) 21 100 (37) 1 845 (3) 98
Australian Capital Territory 148 (55) 68 (25) 54 (20) 0 (0) 100
Victoria 8 301 (53) 3 488 (23) 3 489 (23) 211 (1) 98
Tasmania 3 296 (59) 998 (18) 1 177 (21) 114 (2) 100
South Australia 1 384 (17) 2 764 (35) 3 809 (47) 30 (1) 83
Western Australia 7 522 (34) 9 887 (46) 4 190 (19) 286 (1) 86
Northern Territory 9 134 (62) 2 589 (18) 2 790 (19) 15 (1) 71
Total 90 899 (47) 57 673 (30) 40 873 (1) 2 631 (1) 92
Figure 39: Condition of river reaches based on the habitat subindex.

Mapping riparian vegetation

Riparian vegetation plays a particularly important role in maintaining the condition of rivers. Data on the extent and condition of riparian vegetation provides important information for assessing condition of rivers and for strategic planning of catchment-based natural resource management initiatives (e.g. revegetation, weed control, bank stabilisation, habitat protection and monitoring).

Trend information on the extent and condition of riparian vegetation is essential for assessing the effectiveness of policy or management activities, including investment by the Natural Heritage Trust. In the past two decades, the Natural Heritage Trust and its predecessor, the National Landcare Program, have sponsored riparian vegetation management initiatives across Australia. Our ability to evaluate the success of on-ground works and their long-term contribution to the improvement of riparian vegetation has been limited. Prior to work by the Audit, Australia has not had a reach framework with which to compile data, or agreement to comparable monitoring activities.

The estimated cost for a national riparian vegetation map is approximately $9.6 m (NLWRA 2000). In order to achieve an Australia-wide coverage that could become a component of the Audit's National Vegetation Information System (NLWRA 2001c), we require:

Hydrological disturbance

The natural flow baseline was available for only 25% of reaches in the assessment (or 30% of the total river length) making it difficult to measure the extent to which flow regulation and abstraction have affected rivers. Of the regulated and unregulated rivers that could be assessed, over 80% are modified to some extent and nearly 30% are substantially modified (Figure 40). This may be an overestimate of actual changes to flow in the assessment area because the availability of hydrology data is often associated with the level of resource use.

Unregulated rivers

Almost 90% of the river length in the assessed area is unregulated (diversions occur, but flows are not regulated and existing total annual extractions are less than 0.5% of the mean annual flow). Twenty-six percent of this unregulated river length was assessed using data from the Australian Water Resources Assessment 2000 (NLWRA 2001f) (Table 15).

There were no hydrological data to determine the subindices of the hydrological disturbance index for many unregulated river basins. Reaches in these basins were classified as 'largely unmodified', based on an assessment of mean annual flow and where water extraction was less than 0.5% of mean annual flow. This approach allowed over 20% of unregulated river reaches to be assessed. The Stressed Rivers Assessment Program has developed a hydrological stress indicator to assess unregulated basins in New South Wales. These results differ to the Audit findings for the Richmond, Hunter (regulated in the Audit assessment), Paroo, Snowy, Genoa and Lake George river basins. The discrepancies reflect differences in the data available to the assessments and warrant further investigation.

Figure 40: Condition of river reaches based on the hydrological disturbance subindex.
Regulated rivers

Eleven percent of the river length in the assessment area is regulated and hydrological disturbance could be assessed for approximately half of this length. In regulated rivers that could be assessed, the hydrology of approximately 30% of the river length has been modified. The two components of the hydrology most affected are flow duration - one measure of flood frequency (40% of river length is modified) - and seasonal amplitude (30% of river length is modified). This means that the rivers usually flow for longer periods than natural, and seasonal peaks and lows of intermittent systems are evened out to resemble perennial systems (see box p. 59).

Some regulated reaches have well-vegetated catchments, good riparian vegetation and good water quality. These include rivers such as the upper Snowy River and other rivers in alpine regions and central Tasmania.

Table 15: River hydrological disturbance subindex for each State and Territory.
  River length km Regulated (unregulated) % Assessed regulated (unregulated) % Largely unmodified % Moderately modified % Substantially modified % Extensively modified %
Queensland 74 475 8 (92) 48 (22) 86 10 3 1
New South Wales 62 208 18 (82) 65 (7) 13 66 20 1
Australian Capital Territory 283 51 (49) 61 (0) 0 100 0 0
Victoria 16 556 22 (78) 70 (7) 18 49 30 2
Tasmania 5 843 29 (71) 21 (22) 6 51 43 0
South Australia 10 205 10 (90) 48 (31) 30 49 16 5
Western Australia 26 900 4 (94) 0 (29) - - - -
Northern Territory 21 140 1 (99) 0 (90) - - - -
Total 217 610 11 (89) 54 (26) 19 52 28 1

Case Study: Condamine - Balonne Rivers, Queensland

The Audit's capacity to assess hydrological impact across Australia was limited. A detailed study of the ecological condition response to flow regimes of rivers has been conducted in Queensland and serves as an example of how this assessment can be done at a regional scale.

The Queensland Department of Natural Resources and Mines is undertaking intensive research into the interactions between biotic patterns and processes and the flow regimes of rivers. Its primary aim is to identify practical, cost-effective indicators that can be used to measure the success of flow-related strategies outlined in the State's water resource plans. Improved knowledge of ecosystem function and potential quantification of non-flow related impacts are additional benefits.

The project has been specifically designed to identify indicators of ecological condition that respond to an existing primary flow-change gradient. A wide range of indicators are being specifically measured for the study and then analysed to tease out the relative strengths of the various relationships. The second stage of the study will develop hypotheses and design models for testing and, ideally, quantifying the stronger relationships.

The environmental factors collected concurrently include:

Ecosystem indicators measured include:

The Condamine-Balonne catchment in southern Queensland was chosen as the study area because a wide range of flow and landscape disturbance conditions that are suitable for a nested experimental design are present. It is expected that the study will continue for three years.

Preliminary results based on one sampling round indicate good correlations of flow gradients, as well as land use condition, with the fish, macro-invertebrate, phytoplankton and diatom community compositions (e.g. the flow gradients explained up to 46% of the variation in the macro-invertebrate communities, while the land use gradients explained up to 43% of the fish communities' variation; the macroalgae, bacteria and macrophyte communities did not show good correlations to either the flow or land use gradients). Analysis of each ecosystem health indicator is continuing.

Nutrient and suspended sediment loads

Gully and bank erosion, Snowy River (New South Wales).

Gully and bank erosion, Snowy River (New South Wales).

Photo: Cooperative Research Centre for Freshwater Ecology

Nutrient and suspended sediment loads are greater than natural levels for over 90% of the river length in the area assessed, and are severely modified in almost 10% the total river length (Tasmania and the Australia Capital Territory have no reaches in severely modified condition) (Table 16, Figure 41). Increases in total phosphorus and suspended sediment loads are strongly linked to degradation of water quality.

Total phosphorus loads in the rivers assessed have increased on average 2.8 times above natural levels. The average annual export of total phosphorus to the Australian coast from the assessed rivers is estimated as nearly 19 000 tonnes. Over 80% of the river length has suspended sediment loads that are 10-200 times natural loads. Several thousand-fold increases have been estimated in areas where gully and streambank erosion generate high sediment loads.

The processes causing high phosphorus and suspended sediment loads in rivers are linked because, in most regions, much of the phosphorus load is attached to sediment particles. The most likely principal factor generating high phosphorus and sediment loads is loss of vegetation in the catchment or riparian zone, leading to increased hillslope, gully and bank erosion and suspended sediment loads in the river. Main sources of sediment are gully erosion in degraded areas (particularly in south-western Australia) and hillslope erosion where cover is seasonally low through grazing or tillage of cropped lands (mainly in northern Australia) (NLWRA 2001b).

Forested regions in north-east Victoria, Tasmania, and north Queensland were the only areas assessed where existing suspended sediment loads were similar to natural loads.

Figure 41: Condition of river reaches based on the nutrient and suspended sediment load subindex.
Table 16: Nutrient and suspended sediment load subindex for each State and the Australian Capital Territory.
  Total length of reach (km) in each category and percentage of total in parentheses Percentage of total length with data
Largely unmodified Moderately modified Substantially modified Extensively modified
Queensland 2 809 (4) 12 660 (20) 40 347 (64) 7 573 (12) 88
New South Wales 1 692 (3) 23 784 (41) 27 630 (48) 4 678 (8) 97
Australian Capital Territory 9 (3) 89 (33) 172 (64) 0 (0) 100
Victoria 4 419 (29) 5 067 (33) 5 287 (35) 410 (3) 96
Tasmania 3 233 (59) 1 811 (33) 429 (8) 0 (0) 98
South Australia 210 (3) 2 860 (39) 4 112 (55) 203 (3) 76
Western Australia 870 (4) 2 988 (15) 15 759 (78) 461 (2) 98
Total 13 242 (8) 49 258 (29) 93 736 (55) 13 324 (8) 81

Comparison of the aquatic biota and the environment indices

Scores for the two main indices (aquatic biota and environment) would ideally be similar for each basin. The biota index does not demonstrate the same degree of degradation as the environment index. Reasons for this include:

Spatial patterns in the environment index

When the subindices that make up the environment index are statistically analysed, there are patterns of reaches with similar characteristics for habitat, catchment disturbance and nutrient and suspended sediment loads.

The river reaches with the most urgent need for strategic management and rehabilitation are those in highly modified catchments that have lost much of their riparian vegetation and have dams and levees that disrupt movement of biota and material in the river (Figure 42). These reaches are located in parts of the Murray-Darling Basin, south-west Western Australia, western Victoria, and the South Australian wheat-growing areas.

River reaches that have largely unmodified habitat in terms of riparian vegetation, but very high nutrient and suspended sediment loads, and high potential erosion from hill slopes and stream banks are in need of rehabilitation by reducing nutrient and suspended sediment loads (Figure 43). These reaches are located in Queensland, northern coastal New South Wales, western Victoria and south-west Western Australia.

River reaches that are largely unmodified in all aspects (habitat, catchment disturbance and nutrient and suspended sediment loads) are scattered across Australia, and especially in far north Queensland, eastern Victoria and Tasmania. Protective management will ensure their condition is maintained (Figure 44).

Figure 42: River reaches with modified catchments, nutrient and suspended sediment loads, and habitat.

Figure 42: River reaches with modified catchments, nutrient and suspended sediment loads, and habitat.

Note: Groups of reaches
Legend reaches with large unmodified or moderately modified catchment condition, moderately substantially modified nutrient and suspended sediment loads and moderately to extensively modified habitat.
Legend reaches with moderately modified catchment condition, substantially or extensively modified nutrient and suspended sediment loads and substantially or extensively modified habitat.

Data used are assumed to be correct as received from the data suppliers.

Source: National Land and Water Resources Audit, Assessment of River Condition 2001 Database.
© Commonwealth of Australia 2001.

Figure 43: River reaches with largely unmodified catchments and habitat, but very high nutrient and suspended sediment loads.

Figure 43: River reaches with largely unmodified catchments and habitat, but very high nutrient and suspended sediment loads.

Note: Groups of reaches
Legend reaches with largely unmodified or moderately modified catchment condition, substantially or extensively modified nutrient and suspended sediment loads and largely unmodified habitat.
Legend reaches with largely unmodified or moderately modified catchment condition, moderately or substantially modified nutrient and suspended sediment loads and largely unmodified habitat.
Legend reaches with largely unmodified catchment condition, substantially or extensively modified nutrient and suspended sediment loads and largely unmodified or moderately modified habitat.

Data used are assumed to be correct as received from the data suppliers.

Source: National Land and Water Resources Audit, Assessment of River Condition 2001 Database.
© Commonwealth of Australia 2001.

Figure 44: River reaches that are largely unmodified in all aspects (habitat, catchments and nutrient and suspended sediment loads).

Figure 44: River reaches that are largely unmodified in all aspects (habitat, catchments and nutrient and suspended sediment loads).

Note: Groups of reaches
Legend reaches with largely unmodified or moderately modified habitat, largely unmodified or moderately modified nutrient and suspended sediment loads.

Data used are assumed to be correct as received from the data suppliers.

Source: National Land and Water Resources Audit, Assessment of River Condition 2001 Database.
© Commonwealth of Australia 2001.

Before you download

Most publications are downloadable as PDF files. Adobe Acrobat Reader  is required to view PDF files.

If you are unable to access a publication, please contact us to organise a suitable alternative format.

Key

   Links to an another web site
   Opens a pop-up window